In real estate, there’s a term I use often: “buying the market.” It sounds like an investment strategy, but in reality, it’s a warning sign. It happens when a real estate agent tells a homeowner exactly what they want to hear about their home’s value just to secure the listing—regardless of whether that number is realistic.
It feels good in the moment. You hear a high price, and you start envisioning an incredible payday. But here’s the hard truth: pricing a home above market value drastically reduces your chances of selling quickly and for top dollar. In fact, it often leads to selling for less than you would have if you had priced correctly from the start.
Understanding Buyer Behavior: The Power of Pricing
Buyers have choices. They’re actively comparing homes, analyzing value, and making decisions based on market-driven prices. Here’s how pricing affects exposure:
- At market value: Approximately 60% of potential buyers will look at your home.
- 10% below market: Your exposure jumps to 75% of potential buyers.
- 10% above market: Only 30% of buyers will consider your home.
- 15% above market: A mere 10% of buyers might take a look.
This is critical because selling a home is a numbers game. The more buyers who see your property, the more competition you create. More competition means better offers and a higher likelihood of securing the best possible price. Overpricing shrinks your buyer pool, leading to fewer showings, longer days on market, and ultimately, lower offers.
The Dangerous Cycle of Overpricing
When a home is overpriced from day one, it typically sits on the market longer. And in real estate, time is not your friend. The longer a listing lingers, the more buyers assume something is wrong with it. They start wondering: Why hasn’t it sold? Is there a problem? Is the seller getting desperate?
Eventually, price reductions become necessary. The problem? By the time you lower the price, the listing has already gone stale. The momentum is lost. And when you chase the market downward, you often end up selling for less than you would have if you had priced correctly from the start.
The Illusion of a High Listing Price
Sellers often think: Why not try a high price? We can always lower it later. But that’s a risky approach. The best chance to capture buyer attention is the moment your home hits the market—that’s when excitement is highest. If you squander that opportunity with an unrealistic price, you miss out on your best buyers.
A skilled real estate professional will provide an honest, data-backed assessment of your home’s market value. They won’t attempt to buy the market and inflate the number just to win your listing. They understand that pricing right from the start is the key to maximizing your sale price.
How to Avoid Falling Into the Overpricing Trap
- Demand Market Data – Your agent should present a comparative market analysis (CMA) with recent sales, active listings, and expired properties.
- Understand Buyer Psychology – More buyers mean more competition, which leads to better offers. Overpricing limits your pool.
- Resist the Ego Trap – Your home is valuable, but so is the buyer’s perception of value. The market determines the price, not personal attachment.
- Watch Days on Market – Homes that sit unsold for too long raise red flags and invite lowball offers.
- Choose the Right Agent – Work with someone who prioritizes your success over winning your business with false promises.
Remember, A Smart Strategy Wins
The agent who tells you the highest price isn’t necessarily the best agent. The best agent is the one who gives you the right price—based on reality, not wishful thinking.
Selling your home is a business decision, and the market—not you, not your agent—determines what buyers will pay. If you want to sell for the best possible price, start with an honest evaluation, price strategically, and let the market do the rest and do not fall prey to the buy the market mentality. That’s how you truly win in real estate.
Great article!